六本木ヒルズライブラリー
Heated discussion on a Friday evening
英語で語ろう友の会 2012年11月の定例会
メンバーズ・コミュニティ
更新日 : 2012年12月14日
(金)
2012年11月30日(金)19:00~21:00
12 members joined at the monthly meeting on 30th of November.
Its beginning was Saito-san's introduction, a facilitator of the community, of his experience of illness.
Recently there were some news about the illness from norovirus, so we should take much care of ourselves.
Its beginning was Saito-san's introduction, a facilitator of the community, of his experience of illness.
Recently there were some news about the illness from norovirus, so we should take much care of ourselves.
The first topic was the decline of the number of Japanese students studying abroad. According to the article of Monday, August 20, 2012 in The Japan Times, its number in 2007 was 56,060 and the latest figure is 45,556, so the rate of decline is by about minus 19 per cent. We were asked why the student number declined. Was it because of IT such as an SNS and programs on the net, or was it due to the changes of economic situations and the difficulty of getting a job in Japan for students studying abroad, or something else? Some agreed on the opinions basically and others talked about the minds; the mindsets of students changed. So, our discussion moved to a student's mentality and motivation. Compared to an Asian student' motivation, it's said the Japanese one is not specific, not strong, and inward-looking. However, the recent students have taken part in some activities as volunteers and some universities have encouraged them to do so. The next question was the relation between inward-looking and motivation. Honestly speaking, this topic confused us a little. It was a kind of a matter of sociology: why they have little interest in the outside world, why they participate in volunteer activities. Some members developed their ideas from the viewpoint of the social security system, using examples of the Scandinavia countries. Some talked about the advantages of volunteer experiences when interviewing at a company. Anyway, it seemed to need some knowledge or backgrounds of sociology.
The second was Education minister Makiko Tanaka's decisions. She rejected recommendation to establish 3 new universities. So, the topics were her decision, the quality levels of the recent universities, and the numbers of university. Many members delivered their views of her irrational decision, especially its timing. Strangely, there was no opinion to support her. In retrospect, there might be a viewpoint of a matter of leadership. For example, if a minister only accepts recommendations, then what is their roles? Sometimes leaders need to say 'No' even though the majority say 'Yes'. The top position requires us to have insight and wisdom. Now a drop in academic ability is concerned, and thus her views are very meaningful, I believe.
The third was about the company's culture towards working women. At first, a facilitator seemed to try to pick it up as a debate issue. However, the atmosphere stayed a little chilly. Pregnant women often have passed a promotion up, so is it acceptable or inevitable? What roles do husbands, companies and communities play in? A member said she didn't feel about any gender discriminations at her company. Perhaps, it seems a rare example. In general, there is a strong relation between a business performance and a promotion. Anyway, since the topic consists of several viewpoints such as a company's culture, a relationship with a community, the social values or so, the discussion was not so active.
The debate was the publisher of the Shukan Asahi weekly magazine. They ran the article of the Osaka mayor, Toru Hashimoto and had a huge criticism from a readership and people. So they couldn't help but apology to him publicly. The issue was whether they should be abolished or not. The affirmative side was 8 members and the negative was 3 ones.
The affirmative explained as follows;
- The mass media is one of authority, so they have to use their power very carefully, considering about fairness. However, they failed. They did the wrong things.
- Everyone has privacy, even though public people like politicians have it. The article referred to the birth and lineage that the majority considered very inappropriate, and many believed they exposed the privacy too much.
- The media's mission is to make efforts to improve our society and create a more comfortable one. However, what they did was the opposite. Therefore, their behaviors were equal to being abolished.
On the other hand, the negative presented;
- It was a matter of freedom of speech and the article was within an acceptable level.
- The purpose of the article was to enlighten our ways of thinking and provide the problems brought by him, not give mental abuse.
- The media's role was to inform a lot of people about facts. And the facts themselves were correct. Therefore, forcing to cease their publication would go beyond the acceptable level.
After expressing the reasons, we asked some questions each other; the relationship between freedom of speech and abuse of power; facts between the known and the unknown.
I believe a way of thinking like ‘Pyramid Principle’ or ‘Strucured Thinking’ is necessary in debate.
Senya Miura
The affirmative explained as follows;
- The mass media is one of authority, so they have to use their power very carefully, considering about fairness. However, they failed. They did the wrong things.
- Everyone has privacy, even though public people like politicians have it. The article referred to the birth and lineage that the majority considered very inappropriate, and many believed they exposed the privacy too much.
- The media's mission is to make efforts to improve our society and create a more comfortable one. However, what they did was the opposite. Therefore, their behaviors were equal to being abolished.
On the other hand, the negative presented;
- It was a matter of freedom of speech and the article was within an acceptable level.
- The purpose of the article was to enlighten our ways of thinking and provide the problems brought by him, not give mental abuse.
- The media's role was to inform a lot of people about facts. And the facts themselves were correct. Therefore, forcing to cease their publication would go beyond the acceptable level.
After expressing the reasons, we asked some questions each other; the relationship between freedom of speech and abuse of power; facts between the known and the unknown.
I believe a way of thinking like ‘Pyramid Principle’ or ‘Strucured Thinking’ is necessary in debate.
Senya Miura
注目の記事
-
03月26日 (火) 更新
動的書房 ~生物学者・福岡伸一の書棚
目利きの読み手でもある生物学者の福岡伸一による、六本木ヒルズライブラリーのための選書書棚「動的書房」。2024年3月に新たに21冊が並びまし....
-
03月26日 (火) 更新
本には、人生を変え、時代を創るパワーがある!
2023年4月から2024年2月まで全6回で開催したシリーズ「編集者の視点〜時代を共に創る〜」。モデレーターの干場弓子さんと何度も企画会....
シリーズ編集者の視点〜時代を共に創る〜 <編集後記>
-
03月26日 (火) 更新
【重要】「アカデミーヒルズ」閉館のお知らせ
「アカデミーヒルズ」は、2024年6月30日をもって閉館させていただくこととなりました。これまでのご利用ありがとうございました。閉館までの間....
現在募集中のイベント
-
開催日 : 04月09日 (火) 12:00~12:45 / 04月09日 (火) 19:00~19:45
ゆる~くつながろう!メンバー雑談
テーマなし!年齢制限なし!ライブラリーメンバーなら誰でも参加できる雑談イベントです。肩の力を抜いて楽しく、そしてリラックスした45分を過ごし....
-
開催日 : 04月19日 (金) 19:00~20:30
地図・絵画・日記が語る
江戸時代は厳格な身分制社会の一方で、身分や職業を超えた文化交流の場が形成され、技術と文化の発展を促しました。その中で「浮世絵」は情報メディア....
江戸の「街づくり」「モノづくり」の遺伝子
-
開催日 : 05月02日 (木) 見学ツアー11:00〜12:00/オルガン・プレコンサート13:40~/コンサート14:00〜16:00頃
【メンバー対象イベント】日本フィル&サントリーホール
平日2時のクラシックコンサート「にじクラ~トークと笑顔と、音楽と」のリハーサルを体験しませんか?俳優・高橋克典さんがナビゲーターとなり、上質....
「にじクラ」リハーサル見学・ロビーツアー&昼公演鑑賞